Skip to main content

Kozol~ Argument


In this article, Kozol argues that these low income people often strive for an escape from poverty, although is it likely unrealistic and also, that children suffer from this defenselessly.  A majority of the article focuses in on Kozol's experience with a young boy from the South Bronx, specifically Mott Haven.  It amazes me how positive and inspiring this young boy, Cliffie, is.  By Kozol including the specifics of his time spent with Cliffie, it sends a powerful message to readers.  The message being that almost all of the kids growing up under these conditions do not know any better.  A typical day for young Cliffie includes seeing prostitutes, drug deals and dying/suffering people on his street corners.  There is a waste incinerator that the children call "the place where the dead bodies go".  The local playgrounds contain old, beat up teddy bears for the children to admire while drug deals and needle donations occur with their parents.  Cliffie appears to be such an intelligent boy, full of potential, yet who knows if he will make it out of the conditions he is living in.  Similar to most kids there.  As outsiders, we tend to find ourselves thinking, "well if you want a better life then go make one for yourself", but is it that simple? We may assume so, although regardless of the measures they may try to take, or how hard they work, the system is simply against them.  Food stamps often get stolen, welfare is turned on and off, there is a shortage of nurses in hospitals and job opportunities are lacking.  As imagined, this same depressing scenario applies to the school systems as well.  A lack of teachers, a lack of school supplies and a lack of eagerness to attend.  It absolutely breaks my heart that these people, especially the children, are trapped in this cage of misery and suffering.  Kozol's points and arguments on this subject matter make me wonder as a future teacher the small, yet meaningful, steps I could take to improve the lives of suffering children. 














https://www.enotes.com/topics/amazing-grace-jonathan-kozol 

As for the Black Lives Matter vs. All Lives Matter subject, this is a tough one.  While both statements are true, the addition of one to the other can lessen the meaning of the other.  To be more specific, when the phrase "all lives matter" follows "black lives matter", it is as if they are disregarding the reason people say "black lives matter" to begin with.  This phrase is in play because of the racism and and segregation that black people face.  When people fire back with "all lives matter", the emphasis on equality almost fades away, ironically.  By saying all lives matter, we are avoiding the problem by pretending like there is not one in existence and that we are all in equal standing.  Ww know that's not the case.  Of course everyones life matters, but we should not say that as a solution to the segregation African American's are trying to bring attention to.








Comments

  1. I really like the picture you put of Kozol because of the quote. It is true that test scores do not define a student and I think that needs to be more widely accepted.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This article defiantly reminded me that there are some circumstances where it is much harder to get out of and their is definitely more the society and country can do to help.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I appreciate how you focus on conditions. Children may be "suffering" as you say but Kozol's depiction of Cliffe is also one of hope, strong relationships with family, resiliency, and knowledge. How do schools recognize this in students (if at all?)

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Kliewer and Shor~ hyperlinks

Reading these articles, especially Kliewer's on disability, my mind started evaluating my own experiences with disabilities in my field placement.  Disabilities are far more than downs syndrome or any physical limitations.  For example, ADHD, ADD, dyslexia, and much more.  I have witnessed this first hand and these disabilities certainly have an effect on learning.  Rather than brushing off these "minor" drawbacks, they should be tended to in the best way to encourage that student to excel in school.  Below I attached some articles that relate to this topic and I found very interesting.   What ADHD can look like in a classroom.   What to look for and how to help.   The troubling cases of anxiety found in classrooms.  This link is very educational on the many forms of anxiety and how they are brought into the school and the best ways to deal with it.  This disability can lead to absences, inattention, disruptiveness and m...

Kristof ~ Quotes

After reading the article by Kristof a few times through, I decided on a few key points he made that I would like to agree with/reflect on. "Yet I fear that by 2015 we’ve become the socially rigid society our forebears fled" Centuries ago, the united states was inhabited by those who wanted to escape the harsh circumstances they were living under. This country became a place of freedom that people longed to live among. Kristof makes a point that as time is going on and we are in present day, this country that was once a sanctuary has become more similar to those places our ancestors fled. This is so sad to me as a young adult who still has so much more life to live, unaware of god knows what will happen next in this country. "The chance of a person who was born to a family in the bottom 10 percent of the income distribution rising to the top 10 percent as an adult is about the same as the chance that a dad who is 5 feet 6 inches tall having a son who grows up ...